We Tasted Every Strange, Unholy Taste of Peeps

We Tasted Every Strange, Unholy Taste of Peeps

Peeps Flavors from Finest to Worst, We Tasted Them All

Easter is best around the corner (simply ask Kanye West), which indicates we remain in the thick of Peeps Season. As soon as a relatively fundamental basket-stuffer, just recently there’s been a quick growth in Peeps taste choices. We collected our group for a trial run of a few of this year’s odd, abnormal– and, sometimes, even remarkably excellent– varietals, and ranked them from tastiest to garbage.

Orange Sherbet

orange sherbert peeps taste test ranking

Picture: Adam Corey Thomas

The general winner in our trial run was this orange dreamsicle-like Peep. The incredible orange taste worked completely with the marshmallow taste and texture, and the dip of “creme” at the bottom. The only individual who didn’t like this one was the individual who stanned for the fruit punch, which we’ll go back to (much) later on. The pastel orange color was likewise considered to be “exceptionally Instagram fashionable,” which is the greatest compliment anything can get.

Strawberry Creme

strawberry Creme Peeps flavors taste test ranking

Photo: Adam Corey Thomas

” Strawberry shortcake in an actually fantastic method,” raved one cup. The taste and texture of the strawberry marshmallow and vanilla dip were popular. The only grievance: Red speckles on the pink Peep flesh made a number of cups consider gruesome blood spatters.

Sour Watermelon

sour watermelon peeps flavors taste test ranking

Photo: Adam Corey Thomas

The panel was divided along a clear line: Those who had fond memories of consuming watermelon Airheads as a kid enjoyed this one, those who did not passed. While it was available in with a quite high ranking, the additional stretchy, soft texture and hot pink interior didn’t do it any favors.

Vanilla Creme

vanilla creme peep flavors taste test ranking

While it carried out well in our ranking, no cup had the ability to precisely select what the taste was that Peeps was opting for here; guesses consisted of “marshmallow” and “some sort of cake, however much better than the other cake one.” The texture, speckles, and dip all worked.

Fairy Floss

cotton candy peeps flavors taste test ranking

Photo: Adam Corey Thomas

The Fairy floss Peep nails marshmallow and fairy floss in such a way that was general quite pleasing. Customers particularly valued the blue speckles, which include a bit of crunch and texture variation.

Celebration Cake

party cake peeps flavor taste test ranking

Photo: Adam Corey Thomas

” Odors like an inexpensive candle light,” stated one cup, met a wave of arrangement from the panel. However some individuals like inexpensive candle lights; one customer significant Celebration Care as her preferred in the whole tasting, pointing out a “toasted marshmallow” taste.

Fruit Punch

fruit punch peeps flavor ranking taste test

Photo: Adam Corey Thomas

The color states “Hot Cheeto,” however the overpoweringly extreme fragrance states “grade school juice box” as quickly as the bundle opens. Cups discussed notes of Swedish Fish, however did not like the “tart aftertaste.” For others, it was more difficult to put a finger on why the experience was so undesirable. “It simply truly wigs me out, I can’t discuss it,” stated one.

Chocolate Caramel Swirl

chocolate caramel swirl peeps flavors tate test ranking

Photo: Adam Corey Thomas

We had high expect this one, offered how well the other choices in the Peeps Thrills line fared, however this filled offering was a failure with our panel, numerous of whom bit into the peep not anticipating a caramel-like ooze to come out. “This resembles a 3 Musketeers bar, however awful,” one customer stated. “The caramel things appears like it’s made from plastic,” kept in mind another. (Note: We stopped working to get a great picture of the Chocolate Caramel Swirl Peeps since they actually melted on our art director’s desk upon being gotten rid of from the bundle. Oops.)

Pancakes and Syrup

pancake peeps flavor 2019

Photo: Adam Corey Thomas

” It sort of smells like a McGriddle, however … bad,” a cup kept in mind. That it was a chemical approximation of the pancake and maple syrup taste came through to the panel without triggering, however that didn’t make them like it more. “I associate this odor and taste with a various texture, pancake texture, and getting the marshmallow mush is making my brain go nuts.”

Root Beer Float

Root Beer float Peeps flavor

Photo: Adam Corey Thomas

The visual look of the Root Beer Float Peep is incredibly comparable to the poop emoji, however that’s not why it was our bottom-ranked taste in the test. “I believed this was going to be, like, cinnamon bun taste,” stated one cup, after taking a look at the sample. “I’m truly, truly dissatisfied.” The very best anybody might state about it was that it had a “licorice-like” taste, however the individual who stated that dislikes licorice.

RELATED: We Ranked the Leading 14 Brand Names of Greek Yogurt, Even If

Remain on top of the most recent in L.A. food and culture. Register For our newsletters today.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here